Have you ever tried anal play or anal sex? Most people know about this and many are doing this kinky pleasure. But before you dive into anal play or anal sex, you must know the basics first. Anal foreplay will add up the spice by stimulating the outer part of your anus to make the sphincter more relaxed and will turn the mood to become fully aroused. This can be easily achieved with the help of a butt plug. And what makes it more interesting about this anal stimulating toy is the tailed butt plugs – where many people love role-playing as a pet during their sex.

Pet play is an interesting and pleasurable type of sexual activity where most people who are doing this enjoys the different sides of this steamy pet roleplay. Most partners who practiced pet play have proven that roleplaying releases their wild side without boundaries which makes their sex more engaging. And as an acting pet, the role will be not complete without a tail – and the uncommon fetish will start having a butt plug with a tail.

What Is A Butt Plug With A Tail

Since roleplaying as a pet is a part of stimulating both partners’ sex drive before or during sex, butt plugs with a tail were created to support the role of a pet. Psychologically, a butt plug with a tail can instantly turn someone into a vigorous and hungry animal lying in bed while waiting excitedly for their owners to come.

There are many types of butt plug tails and it represents the type of animal someone uses in pet roleplaying. So, choosing the type of animal you want matters – you can’t roleplay a dog and you’re sticking a foxtail butt plug on your ass. So, if you don’t have any idea what the butt plug tails look like, don’t worry! Here, we will give you the best butt plugs with tails that you must see.

Menu:

Best Butt Plugs With A Tail That You Shouldn’t Miss

#10. Butt Plug With Tail (Cat): Bad Kitty Silicone Cat Tail Anal Plug

Want to purr while your partner is caressing you? Another furry tail butt plug created by Frisky will unleash the inner cat in you.  The kitty butt plug looks simple but it is the best choice for beginners because it has a handy butt plug base where you can pull it out gently without damaging the tail.

Bad Kitty Silicone Cat Tail Anal Plug

Brand: Tailz

Store Available: amazon.com

Price: $28.35

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.4 inches

Insertable Length: 4 inches

Product Total Length: 28 inches

Pros:

  • Best for beginners
  • The plug is silicone-made material
  • Non-porous
  • Loop for vibration
  • Soft tail made of faux fur
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Bendable tail

Cons:

  • Slight difficult to clean

#9. Butt Plug Tail (Cony): Bunny Tail Butt Plug By Tailz

Want to experience a shivering sensation with a bunny tail stuck into your butt? Tailz has created this aluminum metal bunny tail butt plug that has a rippled design on the plug. The bunny tail is made of faux fur in a round shape.

Bunny Tail Butt Plug By Tailz

Brand: Tailz

Store Available: wildsecrets.com

Price: $22.99

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.15 inches

Insertable Length: 2 inches

Product Total Length: 5 inches

Pros:

  • Best for beginners
  • The plug is made of Aluminum perfect for temperature play
  • Non-porous
  • Bunny tail made of faux fur
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Rippled design plug for a wonderful sensation
  • The weight is light

Cons:

  • Too small to use for non-beginner

#8. Butt Plug With Tail (Puppy): Woof Puppy Tail Butt Plug

Express your happiness like a puppy wagging its tail because Master Series just created a very cute puppy tail butt plug just for you. Its plug is designed for a bigger insertion on your anus, so it’s suitable for pro users. The tail is simple like a hairless terrier tail but with a wild side on the plug part.

Woof Puppy Tail Butt Plug

Brand: Master Series

Store Available: amazon.com

Price: $35.64

Product Dimension:

Width: 2.4 inches

Insertable Length: 4.25 inches

Product Total Length: 12.7 inches

Pros:

  • Best for experienced users
  • The plug is made of silicone
  • Non-porous
  • Massive tail plug
  • Easy to clean
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Great stimulation

Cons:

  • Too big for beginners

#7. Foxtail Butt Plug: Glass Anal Plug with Long Fox Tail

Be defensive like a howling fox when trying this fox tail butt plug. The plug is perfectly designed for both beginners and experienced users. Easy to do anal penetration with its smooth tapered tip.

Glass Anal Plug with Long Fox Tail

Brand: Tailz

Store Available: wildsecrets.com

Price: $29.99

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.5 inches

Insertable Length: 4 inches

Product Total Length: 17 inches

Pros:

  • Best for beginners and experienced users
  • Mid-size plug
  • The plug is made of borosilicate glass
  • Long fluffy fox tail
  • Durable
  • Tapered and smooth
  • Great stimulation

Cons:

  • Not a good choice for experienced users who love big penetration.

#6. Butt Plug Tail (Rabbit): Sexysamba Rabbit Tail Butt Plug

Jump like a bunny while playing with SexySamba butt plug. With its fulfilling sensation of the smooth round, fur tail unleashes its powerful vibrations for spine-tingle pleasure. The voyeur will become horny seeing the roleplaying pet wearing the bunny tail during intimate play.

Sexysamba Rabbit Tail Butt Plug

Brand: Sexysamba

Store Available: amazon.com

Product Dimension:

Large: 90mm in length and 40mm in diameter

Medium: 80mm in length and 34mm in diameter

Small: 70mm in length and 28mm in diameter

Tail diameter: 90mm

Pros:

  • Best for both beginners and experienced users
  • Available in 3 sizes – suitable for male and female
  • Tail looks super-sexy
  • Great stimulation

Cons:

  • No specific details on the material.

#5. Foxtail Butt Plug: Foxxxy Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug

Wag your foxy tail while enjoying your sensual anal penetration with Foxxxy Fox Tail glass butt plug. Take your booty pleasure more intensely with a cold-snapping stimulation with the Foxxxy’s glass-made plug after taking it out of the fridge.

Foxxxy Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug

Brand: Frisky

Store Available: adameve.com

Price: $39.95

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.46 inches

Insertable Length: 4 inches

Product Total Length: 13.5 inches (plug – 4.5 inches, tail – 9 inches )

Pros:

  • Best for beginners and experienced users
  • The plug is made of borosilicate glass
  • Long fluffy fox tail
  • Durable
  • Good mixing color of brown and beige
  • Great stimulation

Cons:

  • The tail is short, some users might not love a short foxtail.

#4. Butt Plug With Tail (Wolf): Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug with Wolf Tail & Matching Ears (Grey)

Want to become wilder in bed transforming into a wolf? Tailz just created a wolf tail butt plug with matching ears that will work for your wild and vigorous bed scene. As you are wearing both ears and tails of a wolf will make your steamy play more engaging.

Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug with Wolf Tail & Matching Ears (Grey)

Brand: Tailz

Store Available: shevibe.com

Price: $55

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.75 inches

Insertable Length: 4 inches

Product Total Length: 23.5 inches (4.5 inches plug, tail: 19 inches)

Pros:

  • Best for beginners and experienced users
  • Butt plug paired with ears
  • The plug is made of silicone
  • Long ultra-soft and fluffy faux fur tail
  • Good quality
  • Great stimulation

Cons:

  • Need a large amount of lube for insertion.

#3. Pony Tail Butt Plug: Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail

Do you love My Little Pony? Then you might love roleplaying My Little Pony on your pet play because Crystal Delight just made My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail butt plug. It has a large plug made of glass good for experienced users with matching colorful ponytail to shake.

Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail

Brand: Crystal Delights

Store Available: shop.kinkly.com

Price: $124.99

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.3 inches

Insertable Length: 2.8 inches

Product Total Length: 15 inches

Pros:

  • Best for experienced users
  • The plug is made of borosilicate glass good for temperature play
  • Colorful soft and fluffy faux tail like My Little Pony
  • Good quality
  • Easy to clean with a detachable tail

Cons:

  • Expensive price

#2. Butt Plug With Tail (Fox): Fiesty Greyback Fox Tail Butt Plug

Get wild in bed while roleplaying a fox with Fiesty Greyback fox tail butt plug. It has a faux fur tail of a fox with a slightly pointed silicone-made butt plug good for gentle penetration.

Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail

Brand: Feisty Greyback by Lovegasm

Store Available: lovegasm.com

Price: $28.99

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.18 inches

Insertable Length: 2.80 inches

Product Total Length: 15.75 inches

Pros:

  • Best for beginners
  • The plug is made of silicone made material
  • Soft and fluffy faux tail
  • Good quality
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Experienced users might not love using this small-sized plug.

#1. Butt Plug With Tail (Pony): Pink on Pink Glass Detachable Pony Tail Glass Butt Plug

The most mind-blowing butt plug created by Crystal Delight is here! This fanciful handcrafted butt plug has a detachable tail with 13 colored ponytails available to choose from. Added with a smooth plug tip made of borosilicate glass applicable in all lubes for the best experience of anal sensation.

Pink on Pink Glass Detachable Pony Tail Glass Butt Plug

Brand: Crystal Delights

Store Available: crystaldelights.com

Price: $124.95

Product Dimension:

Width: 1.3 inches

Insertable Length: 3.3 inches

Product Total Length: 15.5 inches

Pros:

  • Best for beginners
  • The plug is made of borosilicate glass good for temperature play
  • Colorful soft and fluffy faux ponytail with 13 color detachable tails available.
  • Good quality
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Easy to clean with a detachable tail

Cons:

  • Product is pricy

Butt Plug Tail Guidelines Do’s and Don’ts

Now that you have an idea what kind of tailed butt plug will work for you, it is also important to know the things that you must do or mustn’t do with your tailed butt plug during your pet play.

1. Don’t Use The Tail When Pulling Out The Butt Plug – Usually, tails are glued on the base of the butt plug. So, pulling the plug using the tail is very risky – it might be detached to the base and will ruin your lustful playtime.

2. Don’t Wash The Furry Tail In Dishwashers – Faux fur tails are soft and fluffy. To maintain its quality and softness, avoid washing it in the dishwasher or washing machine unless it was stated in your tailed butt plug manual. Better wash it with lukewarm water with mild soap.

3. Use The Flare Base When Pulling Out the Butt Plug – The safest way to pull out your butt plug is by the flared base. Pull it gently to avoid hurting yourself.

4. Use Lube At All Times – Every time you are using your tailed butt plug, the first thing that you must do is to put lube on the plug because the anus lacks natural lubrication compared to the vagina. You must read the manual carefully to know what type of lube is suitable for your tailed butt plug. If the manual didn’t indicate the lube then the best type of lube to apply is the water-based lube.

If you are a starter and don’t have any idea where to buy your first butt plug, we can help you out; Want To Know? The Anal Sex Toy Shopping Guide For Beginner.

Proper Way Of Cleaning A Butt Plug With Tail

Sex toys need proper care and maintenance and the first thing you must learn before and after using them is to clean them properly. Most sex toys have the same procedures when it comes to cleaning maintenance, however, the butt plug with a tail has some extra things to consider.

Clean The Butt Plug With Tail Before Using It

This is the first thing that you must do, especially when you have your first butt plug with your tail. New butt plugs with tails have some leftover smell from the manufacturing process that you should remove. The same goes with the used butt plugs, they accumulated the smell of your body in every use. So, maintain your butt plug with a tail clean to eliminate infectious bacterias that might harm you or your partner’s body.

To avoid breaking your toy or damaging its material properties when cleaning, you must learn what type of material your butt plug is made of. For silicone and metal-made materials, you can boil or cook them with water because it has a high heating resistance. Adding baking soda is also recommended to remove the smell and bacteria. For glass and TPE materials you can wash them with warm soapy water or spray them with antibacterial soap and rinse it with water.

Maintain The Fluffiness Of The Tail Of Your Butt Plug

Cleaning the tail attached to your butt plug is also required. You can’t just focus on cleaning your butt plug and leave the tail dirty. It would be so nasty to use. It possibly accumulated germs and smells from your body/fluid or even sweat after doing your roleplaying or sticking it during sex.

So, clean your butt plug tail and maintain its fluffiness with a brush – just gently brush it. Make sure to make it dry before brushing it.

Keep The Butt Plug With Tail Dry

After cleaning your tailed butt plug, you need to make sure that it is completely dried out before storing it. Storing butt plugs without drying them out may produce unpleasant smells, especially in closed storage like boxes and bags. That is why drying your sex toy is the proper way how to maintain its cleanliness and put away unpleasant smells when stored.

Storing Butt Plug With Tail

Storing your butt plug is a very important role in looking after them. Some materials of the butt plugs can react to each other, that is why it is not recommended to store in one bag or box without a partition. The best thing to do is to put them individually in a bag before storing them together in one box.

Avoid also storing your sex toys in a warm area that can be hit by direct sunlight. Keep it in a cool dry place or on high shelves. When storing your butt plug with a tail make sure to put it properly to avoid it from deforming or any damage.

Tip: If you want to learn more about butt plugs before buying your first one, we can help you out! Check this; Things To Know Before Buying Your First Butt Plug.

Final Thoughts

Pet play is part of some people’s sexual activity who loves to play a role of a pet while using a butt plug with a tail. It psychologically changes one’s behavior where they can act like a wild animal who’s ready for a wild steamy play in bed with their partner. And here, we discussed the different types of beautiful and sexiest tail butt plugs that you should have.

FAQs

Is it OK to wear a butt plug every day?

It depends on your mood, and how you want it to stick on your butt for extended hours. Some people wear them all day and some are for just an hour. So, it is OK to wear it anytime you want.

Can anal sex have any long-term effects on my body?

Anal sex is perfectly healthy and safe in both the long and short term. As with vaginal sex, there’s a very small risk of leakage and prolapse throughout a lifetime.